In 1994, a building was purchased (417 Arlington Street) to serve as the official church home of Faith Community Church. There were little to no resources to support repairs, so members of the church chipped in with their resources to renovate the building. Others in the community also supported Faith Community Church by providing supplies, including pews and pulpit furniture that were gifted by East White Oak Baptist Church.
As the church grew, the demographic of the members in attendance expanded. People from various racial groups and denominational backgrounds including Baptist, Methodist, Presbyterian, Catholic, Holiness, and other traditions chose Faith Community Church as their place of worship.